Weight Watchers Stopped Working: Why I Said Goodbye to Points

Weight Watchers worked for me.

More than once.

And that’s what made it so confusing when WW stopped working.

The first couple times I cycled through Weight Watchers, I learned how to work the system. I knew how to stretch my points, how to plan my day, and how to make it all fit. And it worked.

How I “Worked the System” on Weight Watchers (Including Alcohol and Points)

I lost 25 pounds in my late 40s because turning 50 was going to be hard enough. I didn’t want to be overweight, too. I followed the plan, tracked my points, and got results. I felt better and I looked better.

And the best part? I could still have wine. It’s amazing how much wine you can fit into 23 points when you build your whole day around it.

I told everyone that I chose my carbs wisely and lived on zero-point foods and Pinot Grigio, avoiding carb-filled snacks and desserts like the plague.

I could look at a plate and estimate the points in seconds. I knew what to eat, what to avoid, and how to make it all work.

And it worked for quite a while.

I thought I had found the perfect balance. I could drink alcohol, stay within my points, and still lose weight. But looking back, that was part of the problem.

Why Weight Watchers Stopped Working

Fast forward a few years…

The 25 pounds I lost had reappeared. And then some.

My BMI was now in the obese range. But I hiked regularly and did Pilates several times a week. I had even given up meat and dairy products. I was convinced I couldn’t be that unhealthy.

But I definitely wasn’t comfortable in this puffier body.

I rejoined WW and we dated casually. I just couldn’t find the commitment I had previously. It seemed harder eating a vegan diet. And I was drinking more wine. There was no way it could fit into 23 points. So I put WW back on the shelf and waited for a sign that would point me in the right direction.

A few years later, I got that sign. I ended up in the hospital with not one, but two health concerns that required immediate lifestyle changes. So I made them.

Step 1 – Say goodbye to my old friend, Pinot Grigio and my other pal, Prosecco.

Step 2 – Recommit to WW (after an appropriate mourning period for the above losses).

Back to Weight Watchers

I went all in with WW this time and it worked. The pounds started coming off. My willpower had never been stronger. I felt like I had been given a new lease on life.

The points system had changed, but all those mental math skills came right back. Once again, I worked the system like a pro. I stayed within my points, tracked my water and exercise and proudly added every charm I earned to my keychain.

Nine months later, I had lost 50 pounds. WW for the win again!

The Celebration Didn’t Last Long

Just a few weeks after earning my 50-pound charm from Weight Watchers, I had major gastrointestinal surgery that changed my entire digestive system.

I lost more weight after the surgery. Now I was actually skinny. And I had no clue what to eat.

So I did something past Terry would never have done

I bought a tub of cookie dough. Every week.

Fats, fruit and veggies didn’t sit well with me anymore, so I lived on lean proteins and carbs. Pasta, rice, bread… and cookie dough.

And honestly? Being skinny was fabulous.

The few times I checked the points on something, I was horrified. My low-fat, carbolicious diet was very high in points. I didn’t care. I had gained a few pounds post-recovery and I was now at my size 6 goal. I could finally commit to a size.

For years, I had not wanted to buy clothes in whatever size I was (12, 14, 16) because that meant I accepted that size. I had fun rebuilding my wardrobe.

Then it happened. I gained a few more pounds and all my new size 6’s were getting tight.

No worries. I knew what to do. It was time to dust off my WW membership. I never canceled anyway.

Not Losing Weight on Weight Watchers Anymore

But it was different this time.

With my new digestive issues, I couldn’t eat the foods I used to eat. My plain, dry bagel was 7 points and my lactose-free cottage cheese was 4 points for ½ cup.

That’s 11 points just for breakfast.

When I added up my daily calories, they were in the 1,400 range, which should work for weight loss for someone my size, but the points were off the charts. I couldn’t eat less. I looked for lower-point options, but my body wasn’t on board. And frankly, some of those fat-free, sugar-free, low-point options had ingredient lists so long that they scared me.

But WW had gotten me this far. What would I do without it?

I froze and did nothing.

I tried to watch what I ate and managed to keep from gaining much more. But I didn’t have any hope of losing without WW on my side. And it wasn’t working for me.

What Changed (And Why It Matters)

For a long time, I thought my problem was willpower. Or consistency.

But the truth was that Weight Watchers had taught me how to follow a system, but it hadn’t taught me how to understand my own habits.

I started to realize something I hadn’t seen before.

I knew how to follow the plan.

But I didn’t know why I was eating the way I was.

I didn’t know how to adjust when my body changed.

And I definitely didn’t know how to maintain my weight without relying on points.

At one point during my WW journey, I was drinking almost a bottle of wine a night and still losing weight. Maybe that sounds like a win, but it also showed me that just because something “fits in my points” doesn’t mean it’s actually helping.

What I Had to Learn Instead

If WW wasn’t right for me, what was? I knew I had to start over.

I needed to learn how to:

• Look at my food without a points filter.
• Understand what actually fueled my body.
• Recognize my habits.
• And most importantly – understand why I was eating in the first place.

Because it wasn’t always about hunger.

If Weight Watchers Isn’t Working for You

If you’re here because Weight Watchers stopped working for you, you’re not crazy. You’re not broken. And you’re definitely not alone.

For a lot of women, the WeightWatchers program works…until it doesn’t.

And when it stops working, it can feel incredibly confusing. You know how to follow the plan. But you don’t know what to do without it.

For me, the biggest shift wasn’t just changing what I ate. It was understanding why I was eating.

Why This Isn’t Just About Food

Because sometimes, what feels like hunger isn’t about food at all.

Something else was triggering those cookie dough cravings.

What’s driving your eating? Now is your time to find out.

You can take the free 3 Triggers Quiz here and see what’s behind your food choices. This free weight loss quiz only takes a few minutes, and most women are surprised by what they discover.

More Posts You May Be Interested In:

I Canceled Weight Watchers. Why Does It Feel Like a Breakup?

Not Losing Weight on Weight Watchers? Reasons & Solutions

Weight Watchers Program for 2026 (with New Changes and Our Review!)

The Turning Point That Helped Me Lose 60 Pounds After Age 50: Terry’s Before & After

350+ Must-Have Weight Watchers Zero Point Foods for 2026 🍎