The Holy Mess Recipe Index

Use this Recipe Finder to sort & search all Holy Mess recipes.

Filter by multiple categories. For example, choose 301-500 Calories, Lunch, and Weight Watchers to select all the WW lunch recipes with moderate calories. You can also search for any ingredient to use what you have in your kitchen or foods you like.

Save your favorite recipes using the heart icon on the right side of your screen. Enjoy!

Calories

0-300

301-500

501+

Course

CoursesAppetizerBreadBreakfastDessertDinnerDrink/SmoothieLunchSaladSide DishSnackSoup

Diet

DietsAnti-InflammatoryDairy-FreeFreezer-FriendlyGluten-FreeLow-calorieLow-CarbMeal PrepVeganVegetarian/MeatlessWeight Watchers

Cooking Method

Cooking MethodsAir FryerInstant PotNinja CreamiOvenSlow CookerStovetop

Ingredients

Ingredientssalt (48)water (34)eggs (24)cinnamon (21)sugar (20)garlic powder (20)butter (18)vanilla extract (17)olive oil (16)egg (16)self-rising flour (13)pepper (13)onion powder (13)black pepper (13)baking powder (13)onion (12)Greek yogurt (12)honey (11)flour (11)cumin (11)plain non-fat Greek yogurt (10)brown sugar (10)salsa (9)lemon juice (9)Italian seasoning (9)garlic (9)chili powder (9)salt and pepper (8)milk (8)zucchini (7)vanilla (7)chicken broth (7)carrots (7)almond milk (7)all purpose flour (7)sea salt (6)oatmeal (6)minced garlic (6)cream cheese (6)cornstarch (6)chocolate chips (6)black beans (6)balsamic vinegar (6)vegetable broth (5)tomatoes (5)season salt (5)Romaine lettuce (5)pumpkin (5)powdered sugar (5)paprika (5)diced tomatoes (5)cooked brown rice (5)chicken breasts (5)celery (5)beef broth (5)applesauce (5)apples (5)tomato paste (4)strawberries (4)Splenda (4)skim milk (4)Red Wine vinegar (4)red onion (4)plain greek yogurt (4)parmesan cheese (4)oil (4)mustard (4)mushrooms (4)lemon (4)large eggs (4)cottage cheese (4)corn (4)cool whip (4)chicken breast (4)Cherry Tomatoes (4)boiling water (4)bay leaves (4)Banana (4)baking soda (4)almond flour (4)white beans (3)turkey breast (3)Topping: (3)Tomato sauce (3)sweetener (3)spinach (3)spaghetti sauce (3)soy sauce (3)sour cream (3)shredded coconut (3)pumpkin pie spice (3)powdered sweetener (3)pecans (3)peanut butter (3)parsley (3)panko crumbs (3)Panko Bread Crumbs (3)Old Bay Seasoning (3)nutmeg (3)non-fat Greek yogurt (3)mozzarella cheese (3)Miracle Whip (3)mini marshmallows (3)kidney beans (3)ground turkey breast (3)grated Parmesan cheese (3)graham cracker crumbs (3)dry mustard (3)dried oregano (3)Dijon Mustard (3)diced onion (3)Cucumber (3)cauliflower rice (3)boneless skinless chicken breasts (3)blueberries (3)Bacon (3)Avocado (3)angel food cake mix (3)worcestershire sauce (2)whipping cream (2)whipped topping (2)vegetable stir fry blend (2)vanilla ice cream (2)unsweetened, plain or vanilla almond milk (2)Unsweetened Almond Breeze (2)tortilla (2)thyme (2)taco seasoning mix (2)strips of bacon (2)stick butter (2)shredded zucchini (2)shredded cheddar cheese (2)shelled edamame or peas (2)rolled or old fashioned oatmeal (2)ricotta cheese (2)refried beans (2)red wine (2)red pepper (2)red pepper flakes (2)Red Bell Pepper (2)raisins (2)Protein Powder (2)pretzels (2)poultry seasoning (2)pineapple (2)peanuts (2)peach slices (2)paper umbrellas (2)Panko Breadcrumbs (2)onions (2)of water (2)of salt (2)oats (2)mini shot-glass size cups (2)mini plastic spoons (2)Maple syrup (2)limes (2)limes- juiced (2)Light ranch dressing (2)light cheddar cheese (2)lemon slices (2)lemon extract (2)heavy whipping cream (2)hard boiled eggs (2)ground pepper (2)ground ginger (2)ground beef (2)Green Onion (2)green bell pepper (2)Grape tomatoes (2)granulated garlic (2)ginger (2)garlic cloves (2)fresh raspberries (2)fresh parsley (2)fresh lemon juice (2)fat free or light Cool Whip (2)extra virgin olive oil (2)egg whites (2)edamame (2)dried basil (2)diced celery (2)diced carrots (2)dash salt (2)Cubed Steaks (2)Crust: (2)cream of mushroom soup (2)cooking spray (2)coconut sugar (2)coconut oil (2)coconut milk (2)cocoa powder (2)Cilantro (2)Chopped onion (2)chopped carrots (2)chickpeas (2)Chia seeds (2)center-cut bacon (2)cayenne pepper (2)canned (2)Cajun spice (2)cajun seasoning (2)Box Blue Raspberry Jello (2)bell pepper (2)bay leaf (2)Barbecue sauce (2)bananas (2)avocado oil (2)apple (2)apple cider vinegar (2)almond extract (2)1 stick butter, melted (2)yellow squash (1)Wilton white chocolate melts (1)Whole wheat spaghetti (1)whole wheat pasta (1)whole oreos (1)whole kernel corn (1)whole grassfed milk (1)whole black peppercorns (1)white sweet potatoes (1)white pepper (1)white onion (1)White candy melts (1)Whiskey (1)whisked pasture raised eggs (1)water or chicken broth (1)water if needed (1)water chestnuts, chopped (1)veggies such as onion (1)vegetables such as celery and baby carrots (1)vegetables of your choice (1)vanilla pudding mix (1)vanilla pudding mix powder (1)Vanilla Cake Mix (1)unsweetened shredded coconut (1)unsweetened cocoa powder (1)unsweetened chocolate (1)unsweetened chocolate Almond Breeze (1)Unsweetened Almond milk (1)unsalted butter (1)unflavored gelatin (1)uncooked lasagna noodles or other pasta. We used a Campanelle pasta because my kids like the shape 😊 (1)turmeric (1)turkey sausage (1)turkey salami (1)turkey pepperoni (1)turkey or chicken (1)turkey or chicken broth (1)turkey carcass (1)tuna (1)Tortillas (1)Toppings: (1)Toppings of your choice (1)tomatoes with green chilis (1)tomato (1)thick slices of bacon (1)Texas toast bread (1)tea bags (1)Take out frozen raspberries and put in refrigerator to thaw. (1)taco seasoning (1)Swerve Brown Sugar (1)sweetened condensed milk (1)sweet potatoes (1)sunbutter (1)sugar-free pudding mix (1)sugar-free pancake syrup (1)sugar-free orange gelatin mix (1)sugar-free cherry pie filling (1)sugar-free cake mix (1)sugar free Cool Whip (1)sticks butter (1)Stewed Tomatoes (1)Stevia (1)Stevia or Monk Fruit (1)stalks of celery; diced (1)stalk celery (1)Sprite (1)sprinkles (1)Spring M&M’s (1)spoonfuls of balsamic reduction (1)Splenda, Stevia, or Monk Fruit powder (1)spice cake mix (1)spaghetti (1)Spaghetti squash (1)spaghetti noodles (1)soy sauce or alternative (1)sour cream or Greek yogurt (1)soft tofu (1)snow peas (1)smoked turkey sausage (1)smoked paprika (1)small turnips (1)small to medium sweet onions (1)small red apple (1)small onion chopped (1)small green apple (1)small glasses or containers (1)small can (1)small bunch Grapes (1)small broccoli florets (1)small box vanilla pudding mix (1)small bowls (1)slices of bacon (1)sliced or slivered almonds (1)sliced onions (1)sliced onion (1)sliced green peppers (1)sliced green onion, green parts only (1)sliced almonds (1)skim or almond milk (1)shredded mozzarella cheese (1)shredded lettuce (1)shredded cheese (1)shredded cheddar (1)shelled sunflower seeds (1)shallot sliced thinly (1)sesame seeds, toasted (1)Sesame seeds for garnish (1)sesame oil (1)semi sweet Chocolate chips (1)scoop vanilla protein powder (1)salt/pepper (1)Salt for sprinkling on top (1)Salt and Pepper to taste (1)salt and pepper to preference (1)Salt & Pepper to taste (1)salad vegetables of choice such as cucumber sugar snap peas, peppers, tomatoes, radishes, carrots, etc. (1)salad greens (1)russet potatoes (1)Rotel with green chilis (1)rosemary (1)romaine lettuce leaves (1)Roma tomatoes (1)Roma tomato (1)rolls (1)ripe avocado (1)rice vinegar (1)rice krispies cereal (1)rice chex (1)rice Chex cereal (1)rib rub of choice. I use this recipe: https://theholymess.com/no-sugar-rib-rub-recipe/ (1)reduced-sodium soy sauce or alternative (1)Reduced-fat cheese of choice such as Babybel, Laughing Cow, or Cabot (1)reduced calorie shredded cheddar cheese (1)red onion; chopped (1)red onion sliced thin (1)red lentils (1)Red Leaf lettuce (1)red grapes (1)red cayenne pepper (1)red and blue food coloring (1)raw vegetables of choice for dipping (1)raw honey (1)Raspberry Sherbet (1)Raspberry Puree: (1)raspberries (1)ranch or blue cheese dressing (1)Ranch dressing (1)ranch dressing mix (1)rack ribs (1)quick oats (1)queso fresco cheese (1)purple cabbage (1)pure maple syrup (1)pudding mix (1)pretzel sticks (1)powdered sugar for dusting (1)powdered erythritol (Splenda, Truvia, Puyre, or powdered sweetener of choice) (1)powder sugar (1)Pork Chops (1)poppy seeds (1)pomegranate seeds (1)pomegranate juice (1)poached eggs (1)plus 1tbs extra virgin olive oil (1)plain (1)plain Greek yogurt or sour cream (1)pkg. strawberry (1)pizza sauce (1)pinto beans (1)pickles (1)pickle (1)Per Salad: (1)per person firm or extra-firm tofu (1)pepperoncini (1)pepperoncini juice (1)pepper flakes (1)pear (1)peanut butter powder (1)peanut butter granola (1)PB2 powdered peanut butter (1)parsley flakes (1)Parmesan (1)parmesan cheese grated (1)pancakes (1)pancake syrup (1)pancake mix (optional, see note) (1)packets dry onion soup mix or homemade alternative (1)packed light brown sugar (1)packages sugar free lime gelatin mix (1)packages sugar free cook and serve vanilla pudding (1)package wooden skewers (1)package of Au Jus Mix (1)package fresh basil (1)oven roasted (1)organic lemons (1)organic chicken broth powder (1)Oreo cookies (1)Oregano (1)oranges (1)orange zest (1)Optional: a little bit of cheese to top it with (1)optional: 1/8 tsp red pepper (1)Optional toppings: (1)Optional additions: shredded colby-jack cheese, freshly chopped cilantro, chopped avocado, jalapeno slices, lime wedges (1)onion-quarted (1)olive or avocado oil (1)Olive oil to drizzle (1)old-fashioned oatmeal (1)Old Fashion Oats (1)of thinly sliced cabbage – we used purple but green works (1)of Salt and Black Pepper (1)of salmon (1)of red pepper flakes (1)of raw fontina cheese (1)of prosciutto (1)of pesto (1)of pancetta (1)of oven roasted turkey deli (1)of onion (1)of olive oil (1)of non-fat milk (1)of Maple Syrup (1)of lean ground beef (1)of hot water (1)of ground beef (1)of grass-fed cheese (1)of garlic (1)of garlic minced (1)of fresh asparagus (1)of freeze dried Strawberries (1)of cut apples (1)of Coconut Oil (1)of Coconut Butter (1)of cilantro (1)of chopped veggies of your choice (1)of celery (1)of celery in long pieces (1)of cayenne (1)of brown rice (1)of bacon or whichever protein you would like (1)of all-purpose or whole wheat flour (1)nutritional yeast (1)Nonfat Greek yogurt (1)natural peanut butter (1)natural chicken (1)Mrs. Dash (1)mozzarella cheese shredded (1)mixed salad greens (1)Mix-ins (optional) (1)mini chocolate chips (1)minced garlic or 1 tsp garlic powder (1)minced fresh oregano (1)minced fresh basil (1)mild or spicy Italian sausage (1)microwave kettle corn (1)melting chocolate- I used candiquik (1)medium zucchini & 1 medium yellow squash (1)medium sweet potatoes (1)medium sized party skewers (1)medium shrimp (1)medium purple beet (1)medium oranges (1)Medium head of cabbage chopped (1)medium carrots (1)medium apple (1)mayo (1)Marshmallows (1)marinara sauce (1)mango (1)MANGO YOGURT DRESSING: (1)mandarin oranges (1)Malbec/red wine of choice (1)maggi (1)Macaroni (1)Lower Sugar Quaker's Instant Oatmeal (2 packets, each packet is about 1 oz) (1)low-calorie sweetener such as Truvia (1)Low sodium chicken broth (1)long skewers (1)lollipop sticks (1)liquid smoke (1)Lipton Onion soup mix (1)Lime (1)lime juice (1)light ranch salad dressing (1)light mayonnaise or Miracle Whip salad dressing (1)light mayonaise (1)light baby bell cheese circle (1)lemons (1)lemon zest (1)leftover stuffing (1)lean turkey sausage patty (1)lean ground turkey or chicken breast (1)lean ground turkey breast (1)lean ground beef (1)large white onion; diced (1)large tomatoes (1)large shrimp (1)large shallots (1)large red potatoes; diced (1)large or two small tart apples (1)large lettuce leaves (1)large head of broccoli (1)large green tomato (1)large golden beet (1)large egg (1)large cucumber (1)large box raspberry jello (1)large board (1)large basil leaves (1)Large Avocado (1)kosher sea salt (1)Kiwis (1)Juice of one orange (1)Juice of half a lemon (1)Juice from half of a lemon (1)juice from 2 lemons (1)Joseph’s pita (1)jelly (1)Jello layer: (1)jar whole large dill pickles (1)jar of pasta sauce (1)Japanese sweet potatoes (1)jalapeno pepper (1)Italian sausage (1)instant vanilla pudding mix (1)instant mashed potatoes (1)Ingredients: (1)Imitation Crab meat (1)ice cubes (1)I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter (1)I also add 1 tsp of salt/pepper and 1/2 tbs to the dough as it is flavorless (1)hot chocolate mix (1)hollandaise sauce (1)Hidden Valley Dip mix (1)Heart shaped silicone mold (1)heaping T corn starch (1)handful of fresh thyme (1)ham lunchmeat slices (1)half white onion; chopped (1)Gummy fish or sharks (1)guar gum (1)ground red pepper (1)ground pork (1)ground mustard (1)ground dry mustard (1)ground cumin (1)ground chicken breast (1)ground cayenne (red) pepper (1)ground beef, sausage (1)ground all spice (1)Greens or lettuce (1)green tea powder (1)green peppers (1)Green beans (1)Greek seasoning (1)grated ginger (1)grassfed raw cheddar (1)grassfed butter (1)grass fed ground beef (1)grapes (1)granulated sugar (1)granulated onion (1)Granny Smith apple (1)graham crackers (1)goat cheese (1)Glaze: (1)Gingerbread cake mix (1)ghee (1)garlic salt (1)garlic minced (1)garlic cloves minced (1)garbanzo beans (1)gala apples (1)fruit, fresh or frozen (1)fruit such as grapes, apple slices, or pears (1)fruit of choice (1)frozen raspberries (1)frozen mango (1)frozen hash browns (1)frozen green beans (1)frozen french fries (1)frozen diced hash brown potatoes (1)frozen cauliflower (1)frozen blueberries (1)Frito's corn chips (1)fresh thyme (1)fresh or frozen blueberries (1)fresh cranberries (1)Fresh cilantro (1)fresh Brussels sprouts (1)fresh blueberries (1)For the streusel crumb: (1)For the cake: (1)For optional Lemon Glaze: (1)For Muffins: (1)For crumb topping: (1)For apple cider glaze: (1)Flax Meal (1)fire roasted tomatoes (1)Filling: (1)feta (1)fat-free sweetened condensed milk (1)fat-free cottage cheese (1)fat-free cool whip (1)fat-free chicken broth (1)fat free refried beans (1)Fat Free Ranch (1)fat free mozzarella (1)fat free mozzarella cheese (1)farro or barley, cooked (1)Everything Bagel seasoning mix (1)elbow macaroni (1)eggs beaten (1)eggplant (1)egg yolks (1)egg yolk (1)egg white (1)egg noodles (1)Easter sprinkles (1)dry-roasted sunflower seeds (1)dry bread crumbs (1)dried, minced onion (1)dried thyme (1)dried thyme leaves (1)dried rosemary (1)dried parsley (1)dried oregano leaves (1)dried onion flakes or dried minced onion (1)dried cranberries (1)dried basil or 1tbs of fresh basil (1)Dough recipe (1)double stuffed oreos (1)distilled white vinegar (for tangy) or apple cider vinegar (for less tang) (1)disposable piping bags (1)disposable aluminum foil tins (1)dill pickle juice (1)Diet lemon lime soda (1)diced zucchini or green peppers (1)diced yellow onion (1)diced red onion (1)diced ham (1)diced green chilis (1)diced green chilies (1)deli ham (1)dates (1)Dash of salt and pepper (1)dash of Paprika (1)dash cinnamon (1)Dark Chocolate (1)crushed pork rinds (1)crushed pineapple, drained (1)crushed peppercorn or Italian seasoning (1)crushed Frosted Flakes (1)crushed fresh raspberries (1)creamy peanut butter (1)cream of tarter (1)Craisins (1)Crackers such as Good Thins, Reduced Fat Wheat Thins, or Pop Chips (1)cracked black pepper (1)crab (1)course salt (1)Country Gravy mix (1)cottage cheese, low fat (1)cornmeal (1)corn kernels (1)corn chex (1)cookie sheet fitted with parchment paper (1)container of fresh mozzarella (1)container of cherry sized mozzarella balls (1)container of arugula (1)container beef broth (1)confectioners sugar (1)coleslaw blend (1)cole slaw mix (1)cold water (1)Cold milk (1)Colby jack cheese (1)coffee (1)coffee creamer (1)coconut milk + 2 Tablespoons (1)Coarse Sea Salt (1)cinnamon sticks (1)chuck roast (1)chuck roast of beef (1)Christmas sprinkles (1)chopped red or white onion (1)chopped garlic (1)chopped fresh broccoli (1)chopped dill pickles (1)chopped cherry tomatoes (1)chopped celery (1)chopped baby spinach (1)chocolate (1)Chocolate Raspberry filling: (1)Chocolate Graham crackers (1)chocolate frosting (1)Chocolate Cups: (1)chocolate cake mix (1)chives or parsley (1)chili sauce (1)chicken stock (1)Chicken Sausage (1)chicken or vegetable stock (1)chicken or vegetable broth (1)chicken or beef stock (1)Chicken drummetts (1)chicken breasts – cut in half length ways to speed cooking (1)chicken breasts tenders (1)cherries (1)cheese slices (1)cheddar cheese (1)celery stalks (1)celery ribs (1)celery finely chopped (1)cashews (1)carrots sliced on diagonal (1)carrots finely chopped (1)carrot chips (1)Carb Quik (1)cara cara oranges; juiced (1)cans diced tomatoes (1)canned crushed pineapple (1)canned black beans (1)candy sprinkles or colored sugar (1)Candy canes (1)can tomato sauce (1)can Rotel with green chilis (1)can quartered artichoke hearts (1)can pumpkin (1)can of tomato sauce (1)can of french onion soup (1)can of crushed tomatoes (1)can mandarin oranges, drained (1)can kidney beans (1)can fire roasted tomatoes (1)can evaporated milk (1)can cream of chicken soup (1)can cranberry sauce (1)can cherry pie filling (1)can black beans (1)can artichoke hearts drained and chopped (1)cabbage (1)button mushrooms (1)butternut squash (1)butter or margarine (1)butter or cake batter extract (1)butter for skillet (1)bundle cilantro; chopped (1)bunches of kale (1)bunches of asparagus (1)bunch red grapes (1)bunch green grapes (1)Buffalo Wing Sauce (1)buffalo chicken sauce (1)brown rice (1)brown gravy mix (1)broccoli (1)broccoli florets (1)boxes sugar free vanilla pudding (1)boxes of Capello's Fettuccine Pasta (1)boxes frozen raspberries. (1)box frozen spinach (1)box frozen chopped spinach (1)boneless skinless chicken tenders (1)bone in short ribs (1)blueberries, raspberries, or strawberries (1)block Monterrey Jack cheese (1)block fresh mozzarella cheese (1)block cheddar cheese (1)black olives (1)Black Eye Peas (1)berries (1)bell peppers (1)Beefsteak tomato (1)beef stew meat (1)Beef Shoulder Roast (1)Beef bones (1)batch homemade or prepared sugar cookie dough (1)basil (1)banana peppers, sliced (1)baking potatoes (1)bags tricolor shredded coleslaw (1)Bags of red candy melts (1)bags Frito's corn chips (1)bag Jolly Ranchers candy (1)bag frozen cauliflower (1)bag fresh Cranberries (1)bacon finely chopped (1)baby spinach (1)baby red potatoes (1)baby dill pickles (1)avocados (1)assorted berries (1)as desired salt and pepper (1)artichoke hearts, drained and chopped (1)arrowroot starch (1)aquafaba (1)approx 2 tsp coarse sea salt (1)apple slices (1)apple pie or pumpkin pie spice (1)apple cider (1)angel food cake (1)American cheese (1)American cheese slice (1)almonds (1)almond milk, unsweetened (1)almond butter (1)Alfredo sauce (1)a few small potatoes (1)a few fresh basil leaves (1)9 oz. package refrigerated three cheese ravioli (1)1/3 less fat cream cheese (1)1/2 cup Rum, Coconut Rum, or Tequila (1)

Instant Pot Weight Watchers Vegetable Soup

CaloriesCalories: 68

Healthier Crustless Pumpkin Pie

CaloriesCalories: 159

Healthier Sheet Pan Taco Pizza Recipe

CaloriesCalories: 369

LaNette’s Copycat Jimmy John’s Unwich

CaloriesCalories: 321

LaNette’s Peanut Butter & Jelly Wrap to Go

CaloriesCalories: 338

LaNette’s Seafood Sensation Wrap Recipe

CaloriesCalories: 298

Healthy Slow Cooker Lemon Herb Turkey Breast with Gravy

CaloriesCalories: 268

Instant Pot One Pot Pasta with Meat Sauce

CaloriesCalories: 340

Sheet Pan Shrimp Boil

CaloriesCalories: 256

The Holy Mess Ninja Creami Natural Ice Cream Recipe

CaloriesCalories: 493

The Holy Mess Ninja Creami Birthday Cake Protein Ice Cream Recipe

CaloriesCalories: 329

The Holy Mess Ninja Creami Vanilla Protein Ice Cream Recipe

CaloriesCalories: 291

Chicken Ranch Salad

CaloriesCalories: 362

Healthier Chicken Salad Recipe with Grapes, Apples, and Pecans

CaloriesCalories: 177

Air Fryer Frozen French Fries

Cottage Cheese Blender Pancakes

CaloriesCalories: 290

Cheesy Broccoli Frittata for Two People

CaloriesCalories: 295

Healthier Copycat McGriddle Sandwiches

CaloriesCalories: 460

Blueberry & Almond Oatmeal Bake {Small Batch}

CaloriesCalories: 196

The Holy Mess Fast & Filling Potato Soup Recipe

CaloriesCalories: 99